Fish Bowls In Bedrooms: Good Idea Or Not?

Fish bowls are a common fixture in many homes, often kept in bedrooms as a decorative element and to add a touch of nature to the space. While some people believe that keeping a fish bowl in the bedroom can enhance the energy of the room and bring good fortune, it is important to consider the ethical implications and the impact on the fish's health and well-being. Fish bowls may seem like a convenient and appealing option for those who want a splash of life without the commitment of a larger aquarium, but they present several challenges that can compromise the health and well-being of the fish.

Fish bowls are not easier to maintain

Secondly, fish bowls restrict oxygen levels. Their small size and tapered shape mean that when filled all the way up, there is insufficient surface area for adequate gas exchange, leading to oxygen deprivation for the fish. While filling the bowl halfway can mitigate this issue, it leaves very little water for the fish to move around in.

Thirdly, the shape of fish bowls makes it difficult to incorporate proper filtration, which is crucial for maintaining water quality and oxygen levels. Typical filtration equipment does not fit well into the odd shape of bowls, and custom-fit filters can be more expensive than a larger, more functional aquarium setup.

Additionally, fish bowls do not provide an ideal environment for fish in terms of space and comfort. Fish need room to swim and explore, as well as hiding places when they feel scared. The curved glass of a fish bowl can distort the fish's view, causing stress and discomfort.

Finally, the open top of a fish bowl poses a danger, as fish can jump out and suffocate. It also leaves the water vulnerable to contamination from toxins or curious pets. Overall, while fish bowls may seem appealing, they are not a suitable or healthy environment for fish and require more expertise and maintenance than most people realise.

Fish bowls aren't stable environments

Fish bowls may seem like a good idea, especially for beginners, but they are not ideal for fish. They may be easy to set up, but they are not easy to maintain. Fish bowls are comparatively less stable than larger aquariums, and physical and chemical parameters tend to swing wildly. Preventing these rapid fluctuations is challenging due to the smaller water volume and typical lack of water filtration.

The smaller water volume in fish bowls means that the temperature can change quickly, which can be fatal for many fish. For example, a bowl kept in the sun versus shade will vary widely in temperature. Most small bowls do not have room for an aquarium heater, so there is no way to keep the water consistently at the proper temperature. This can be a problem for temperate fish and is a severe problem for tropical fish, such as bettas, that require warm water temperatures year-round.

Fish bowls also restrict oxygen levels. The surface area of the air-water interface changes as you fill them, and completely filling them leaves too little water surface for proper gas exchange. Fish can suffocate even in the cleanest water simply because oxygen cannot diffuse into the water as fast as it is consumed. To maximise the size of the water surface, it is best to fill bowls halfway, but this leaves very little water for the fish to move around in.

In addition to temperature instability and oxygen deprivation, fish bowls are also susceptible to extreme changes in water quality. This usually involves setting your fish aside in a small cup while performing a water change and cleaning the bowl. The biggest risk in doing this is a sudden swing in the water pH (acid-base balance). Water in a fish bowl will slowly use up its buffering capacity (carbonate hardness or kH) as your fish breathes and metabolises food. Once the kH is decreased, the pH will start to drop. A sudden, heavy water change will then shoot the pH back to "normal" or tap water level, which can cause serious health issues and even death for your fish.

Fish bowls restrict oxygen levels

Fish bowls are not a good option for keeping fish as they restrict oxygen levels. Fish need oxygen, and while there is some oxygen absorption at the air-water interface, in most instances, the oxygen is used up faster than it can be replenished. This is especially true if the fish are active. The smaller the bowl, the more quickly the oxygen will be used up.

The shape of fish bowls also exacerbates the problem. Bowls taper toward the top, so if they are filled all the way up, there is insufficient surface area for proper gas exchange. The fish can suffocate even in the cleanest water simply because oxygen cannot diffuse into the water quickly enough. Filling the bowl halfway maximises the surface area for gas exchange, but this leaves very little water and, therefore, space for the fish to move around in.

The lack of oxygen in fish bowls is further compounded by the lack of filtration. Filters constantly add oxygen to the water through aeration. In a fish bowl, the only source of oxygen is the surface area, which, as mentioned, is often insufficient.

Fish bowls are also more difficult to maintain than most people realise. They are less stable than aquariums, and physical and chemical parameters tend to swing wildly. Preventing these rapid fluctuations is challenging due to the smaller water volume and typical lack of water filtration.

Fish bowls lack proper filtration

Fish bowls are a popular choice for beginner fishkeepers and those looking for a simple, low-maintenance setup. They are small and easy to set up, making them a great choice for those with limited space or resources. However, it is important to note that fish bowls lack proper filtration, which can lead to unhealthy and unhappy fish.

One of the main issues with fish bowls is the lack of nitrogen cycling. In a standard aquarium, beneficial bacteria grow in the substrate and on the filter, converting the primary fish waste of ammonia into its less toxic component, nitrate. In a fish bowl, the bacteria in the substrate do not get enough oxygen, and the ammonia waste excreted by the fish builds up. This can cause serious health issues and even death for your fish.

Fish bowls also restrict oxygen levels for fish. Due to their small size and shape, fish bowls have a limited surface area for proper gas exchange. Fish can suffocate even in clean water because oxygen cannot diffuse into the water as fast as it is consumed. To maximize the size of the water surface, it is recommended to fill fish bowls halfway, but this leaves very little water for the fish to move around in.

The lack of proper filtration in fish bowls also means that the water quality can fluctuate wildly. Fish living in bowls are often subjected to extreme changes in water quality, especially when performing a water change and cleaning the bowl. A sudden swing in the water pH can be very stressful for fish and can even cause death.

To maintain a healthy environment in a fish bowl, frequent and large water changes are necessary. It is recommended to do a 50-100% water change daily in a fish bowl to remove waste and reduce the fish's exposure to toxic material. However, these massive water changes can be stressful for the fish and require a lot of maintenance.

In conclusion, while fish bowls may seem like a convenient and affordable option, they lack proper filtration and can be challenging to maintain a healthy environment for fish. It is important to consider the needs of the specific species of fish and ensure they have enough space and filtration to thrive.

Fish bowls are inconsistent in temperature

Fish bowls are small, which makes the water susceptible to varying environmental temperatures. A bowl kept in the sun will be much warmer than a bowl kept in the shade. Most small bowls do not have room for a heater, so there is no way to keep the water consistently at the proper temperature. This can be a problem for temperate fish and is a severe problem for tropical fish that require warm water temperatures year-round, such as bettas.

The small volume of water in a fish bowl means that it is difficult to maintain a consistent temperature. The water in a fish bowl will be more strongly influenced by the surrounding temperature, and the smaller the bowl, the more challenging it is to control the water temperature.

The shape of the bowl also affects the temperature regulation. The curved sides of the bowl can distort the fish's view, causing stress for the animal. The round shape also has a poor surface-to-air ratio, which affects the oxygen levels in the water. The rectangular form of an aquarium allows for a larger surface area exposed to the air, which helps to keep oxygen levels up.

The lack of filtration in fish bowls further contributes to the inconsistent temperature. Without proper filtration, the water quality can fluctuate, affecting the fish's health. The water in a fish bowl is also more prone to extreme changes in quality when performing a water change, as the fish is typically placed in a small cup during the cleaning process. These sudden swings in water pH can cause serious health issues or even death for the fish.

In summary, the small size, shape, and lack of filtration of fish bowls make it difficult to maintain consistent temperatures and water quality, which can be detrimental to the health and well-being of the fish.

Frequently asked questions