Sleeping In Separate Bedrooms: Does It Count As Separation?

The concept of a “sleep divorce” or “sleep separation” is becoming increasingly popular, with research suggesting that one in five couples are sleeping separately most or all of the time. While sleeping in separate bedrooms can have benefits for both physical and mental health, it can also raise questions about the legal implications of such an arrangement, particularly in the context of separation and divorce. In the state of Virginia, for example, the law allows for no-fault divorce on the grounds of living separate and apart for one year, or six months with a separation agreement and no minor children. However, what constitutes separate and apart under Virginia law is less clear when a couple lives separately but under the same roof. While sleeping in separate bedrooms does not automatically constitute legal separation, a couple must also demonstrate that they are living separate lives, including refraining from sexual relations and performing day-to-day tasks independently.

A couple must live in separate residences to be considered separated

In Virginia, a couple must live in separate residences to be considered legally separated. Living "separate and apart" is a requirement for a no-fault divorce in the state. While it is possible for spouses to live separately under the same roof, this requires a deliberate approach to their daily lives to demonstrate that they are truly separated.

For a couple to be considered separated while living in the same residence, they must do so in a manner that is obvious to those around them. This includes sleeping in different bedrooms, refraining from sexual relations, and ceasing to perform typical spousal tasks for one another. A Fairfax County Circuit Court judge may ask specific questions to determine if a couple is living separately, such as whether they prepare meals, shop, or eat together.

To further establish separation, a couple should stop holding themselves out as a married couple, both inside and outside the home. This includes no longer wearing wedding rings, attending social functions together, or exchanging gifts on birthdays or holidays. They should also separate their finances and inform family and friends of their separation.

While it is possible for a couple to be considered separated while living in the same residence, it requires a significant change in their daily routines and interactions. The most effective way to prove separation is for one party to move out and live in a separate home. This provides clear evidence of the couple's intention to live apart and demonstrates a physical separation.

In summary, for a couple to be considered legally separated in Virginia, they must live in separate residences and demonstrate an intention to no longer live as husband and wife. While it is possible to be separated under the same roof, it requires a deliberate change in their daily lives and may be more complex to establish.

However, spouses can live separately under the same roof, but they must be deliberate in how they live their daily lives

In Virginia, spouses can live separately under the same roof, but they must be deliberate in how they live their daily lives. To be considered legally separated while living in the same house, couples must meet certain criteria. Firstly, they must sleep in different bedrooms and refrain from sexual relations. Additionally, they should stop doing things that spouses typically do for each other and that they wouldn't usually do for non-family members. This includes tasks such as cooking, cleaning, and doing laundry for each other.

When determining whether a couple is truly living separately, a judge may consider various factors, including whether each spouse prepares their meals, shops, and cares for their own space in the residence. The couple should also stop holding themselves out as a married couple, both inside and outside the home. This includes no longer wearing wedding rings, attending social functions together, or exchanging gifts on birthdays and holidays.

It is important to note that simply sleeping in separate bedrooms does not constitute legal separation. To be legally separated, spouses must live "separate and apart," which typically implies residing in different locations. However, in cases of financial constraints, Virginia courts recognize that spouses may live separately under the same roof during the separation period. In such cases, spouses must deliberately change their daily routines to demonstrate a clear separation.

To establish a clear separation while living in the same residence, spouses should aim to create as many indicators of separation as possible. This includes documenting the intention to end the marriage in writing and stopping all sexual relations and shared use of bedrooms and bathrooms. Spouses should also separate their finances, stop attending events together, and inform family and friends of their separation. These steps help ensure that the parties are no longer deriving the benefits of living with a spouse and are instead treating each other as roommates.

To be legally separated, both parties must be aware that at least one spouse intends to end the marriage

In Virginia, a couple must be separated for at least one year to be granted a no-fault divorce (or six months if they have no minor children and have signed a comprehensive settlement agreement). But what does it mean to be "separated" when a couple continues to live in the same residence?

In determining whether a couple is truly living separate and apart under the same roof, a judge may consider various factors, including whether each spouse prepares their own meals, shops for themselves, and cares for their own space in the residence. The court will also look at whether the couple continues to attend gatherings, vacations, or social functions together, exchange gifts, or celebrate holidays together.

It is important to note that simply sleeping in separate bedrooms does not constitute legal separation. To be considered separated under the same roof, a couple must also make significant changes to their daily routines and interactions to demonstrate that they are no longer living as a married couple.

Couples must stop holding themselves out as a married couple, including no longer wearing wedding rings

In Virginia, couples can be considered separated even if they live in the same home, but they must live "separate and apart". This means that they must sleep in different bedrooms, refrain from sexual relations, and stop doing the sorts of things that married couples do for each other.

If a couple is living separately under the same roof, they must be very deliberate in how they live their daily lives to show that they are truly separated. Here are some guidelines for couples to follow to ensure they are living "separate and apart":

• Stop holding themselves out as a married couple, both inside and outside the residence, including no longer wearing their wedding rings.
• Stop attending gatherings, vacations, or social functions together.
• Stop giving each other rides or facilitating transportation for each other.
• Stop accomplishing day-to-day tasks for one another, such as grocery shopping, cleaning, cooking, and doing laundry. This even includes having their own food in the refrigerator.
• Tell family and friends about their separation.
• Stop celebrating holidays together and exchanging gifts on birthdays, anniversaries, or holidays.
• Establish separate bank accounts and separate their finances if possible.

The purpose of these guidelines is to ensure that the couple is no longer deriving benefits from living with their significant other as a married couple. For all intents and purposes, they should treat each other as roommates rather than spouses.

A court will look very closely at the couple's behaviour to determine whether or not they are truly separated

When it comes to determining whether a couple is truly separated, a court will scrutinise their behaviour, especially when they continue to live under the same roof. This is because, in most cases, a court will not consider a couple separated when they live together.

In the state of Virginia, a no-fault divorce can be granted if a couple has been living "separate and apart" for a year, or for six months if they have no minor children and have a comprehensive settlement agreement in place. While the most definitive way to prove separation is by living in different residences, this is not always financially feasible. Therefore, the Virginia Court of Appeals has acknowledged that spouses may live separately while sharing a residence. However, they must be very deliberate in how they live their daily lives to demonstrate a genuine separation.

In determining whether a couple is truly separated, a court will consider a range of factors, including:

• Whether each spouse prepares their meals, shops, and does their laundry separately.
• Whether the spouses eat meals together, especially when their children are not present.
• Whether each spouse maintains their own space within the shared residence.
• Whether the couple continues to socialise together, such as attending church or synagogue services or social functions as a couple.
• Whether the couple holds themselves out as a married couple, for example, by wearing their wedding rings.
• Whether the spouses exchange gifts on birthdays, anniversaries, or holidays.
• Whether the couple has informed their family and friends about their separation.
• Whether the spouses continue to share a bedroom or bathroom.
• Whether the spouses have separate financial accounts and finances.

It is important to note that there is no single factor that will convince a court of separation when a couple lives under the same roof. Instead, the court will consider the totality of the circumstances and behaviours to determine whether the spouses are truly separated.

Frequently asked questions