Flooring Vs Carpet: Which Is The Cheaper Bedroom Option?

When it comes to flooring, there are many options to choose from, each with its own pros and cons. Two of the most popular choices are carpet and laminate or hardwood flooring. Carpet is generally the more budget-friendly option, with prices ranging from $1 to $11 per square foot, while laminate or hardwood flooring can cost anywhere from $3 to $20 per square foot. However, it's important to consider not only the upfront cost but also the long-term costs associated with each type of flooring. Carpet may need to be replaced more frequently, while laminate or hardwood flooring can last for decades or even a lifetime with proper care. Ultimately, the best choice depends on factors such as budget, lifestyle, and aesthetic preferences.

Carpet is generally cheaper to install than hardwood flooring

The price of carpet depends on the type of fibre, pile height, and overall quality. Carpeting per square foot can range from $2 to $10, but the average price is around $5. The cost of installing carpet also depends on the padding depth, the size of the home, and the type of carpet. Carpet is typically easier to install than hardwood, and it doesn't require expensive tools. However, installing carpet in a room with a poor subfloor condition or an odd shape can be more complicated.

While laminate flooring can be more expensive to install than carpet, it is a more durable and long-lasting option. It is also easier to maintain and clean, as it is more resistant to staining and trapping dirt and allergens than carpet. In the long run, laminate flooring can be a more cost-effective option than carpet, despite its higher upfront cost.

Carpet is a popular choice for bedrooms as it is softer, cozier, and better at reducing noise. It is also a good insulator and helps with heat retention, making it a preferred option in colder climates. However, carpet has a shorter lifespan than hardwood and is more prone to staining. It also requires regular vacuuming and professional cleaning every six months to two years, depending on foot traffic.

Carpet is more susceptible to staining and harder to clean

Carpeting is a popular choice for flooring in bedrooms, and it's easy to see why. It's soft, warm, and does a great job of muffling sound. However, one of its major drawbacks is that it is more susceptible to staining and harder to clean than other flooring options, such as laminate or hardwood.

Carpet is more prone to staining than other types of flooring because it has a larger surface area and is typically made from fibres that are easily stained. Spills and messes can quickly seep into the fibres and become set-in stains. This is especially true for older stains, as they are harder to clean and often require rehydration to be removed. Even without stains, carpeting can harbour dust, dirt, and bacteria that routine vacuuming can't completely remove.

When it comes to cleaning carpet stains, it's important to act quickly. The longer a stain sits, the harder it is to clean. The general process for removing carpet stains involves scraping off any excess solids, blotting the stain with a clean, slightly damp cloth, applying a carpet stain remover or DIY solution, and then blotting the area again. It's important to blot rather than rub or scrub the stain, as this can damage the carpet fibres and cause the stain to spread. Additionally, always use a white cloth or towel to clean, as coloured fabrics can transfer dye to the carpet.

While it is possible to remove many carpet stains with the right techniques and products, some stains may require professional cleaning services. This is especially true for tough, set-in stains or unknown stains, where you may need to try different treatments to find an effective solution. Professional carpet cleaning services can also be beneficial for deep cleaning your carpet every few years to remove built-up dirt, debris, and allergens.

Compared to other flooring options, such as laminate or hardwood, carpet is generally trickier to clean and more vulnerable to stains. Laminate flooring, for example, is non-porous and can be easily cleaned with a broom, damp cloth, or electric mop. Hardwood flooring is also relatively easy to clean and is more stain-resistant than carpet. However, it's important to note that while laminate and hardwood may be more low-maintenance than carpet, they often come with a higher upfront cost.

Hardwood flooring is more durable and lasts longer than carpet

While carpet is generally the more budget-friendly choice, hardwood flooring is more durable and lasts longer.

Carpeting typically has a lifespan of five to 15 years, depending on the amount of foot traffic in the household. If you have kids or pets, you may need to replace your carpet closer to five years. Once the carpet starts to deteriorate, you will likely need to replace the whole thing.

Hardwood flooring, on the other hand, can last 30 to 100 years or more with proper maintenance. Solid hardwood can be sanded down and refinished when it incurs damage, so you won't need to replace the whole floor.

The durability of hardwood flooring is reflected in its upfront cost, which is higher than that of carpeting. The average cost of installing laminate flooring in a 500-square-foot home is around $2,000, while the average cost of installing carpeting is about $1,500.

Laminate flooring, also known as engineered wood, has gained popularity due to its durability and low-maintenance needs. It is non-porous and can be easily cleaned with a broom, damp cloth, or electric mop. Carpeting, on the other hand, requires regular vacuuming to remove surface dirt, bacteria, allergens, and debris, and it needs to be professionally cleaned every six months to two years, depending on foot traffic.

While hardwood flooring may be more expensive initially, it can be a more cost-effective option in the long run due to its durability and longer lifespan compared to carpeting.

Carpet is better at muffling sound and providing insulation

Carpet is a popular flooring option for bedrooms, and for good reason. While laminate or hardwood flooring might be more durable and longer-lasting, carpet is better at muffling sound and providing insulation.

Carpet is an excellent sound absorber. The individual fibres, piles, tufts and underlay of a carpet have different resonant frequencies, allowing them to absorb a wide range of frequencies. This makes carpet ideal for bedrooms, as it can reduce noise from other rooms or apartments, as well as muffle the sound of footsteps. A study by the Danish National Institute of Occupational Health found that more than half of all employees working in open-plan offices are negatively affected by noise. Therefore, carpets can also be beneficial in these environments.

Carpet is also a good insulator. Carpeting can help to retain warm and cool air, reducing energy costs for the homeowner. Materials like metal and marble are good conductors of heat, meaning they allow heat to flow efficiently. Carpet does the opposite. It is a poor conductor, so it allows heat to remain in your body, making you feel warmer. Thicker carpets insulate better than thinner ones, and wall-to-wall carpeting holds more heat than rugs. The R-value of a material represents its insulation level, or the amount of thermal resistance it offers. The higher the R-value, the better the insulation. Carpet has an R-value of around 0.18, which is much higher than concrete, with an R-value of 0.07.

In summary, carpet is a great choice for bedrooms due to its sound-absorbing and insulating properties. It can reduce noise and insulate heat, creating a cosy and peaceful environment.

Hardwood flooring is better for allergy sufferers

When it comes to flooring, there are many options to choose from, each with its own pros and cons. If you're an allergy sufferer, you may want to consider hardwood flooring for several reasons.

Firstly, hardwood floors have a non-porous surface, meaning allergens cannot penetrate and get trapped within the material. This makes it easier to clean and remove allergens, reducing the overall allergen load in your home. A simple sweep or vacuum can effectively remove dust, pet dander, and other allergens from the surface. In comparison, carpets can trap allergens within their fibres, contributing to poor indoor air quality and potentially triggering allergic reactions.

Secondly, hardwood floors are resistant to mould and mildew, whereas carpets can harbour these fungi when exposed to moisture. This resistance is particularly beneficial for individuals allergic to mould and mildew.

Thirdly, hardwood floors tend to last longer than many other types of flooring. This durability means they don't need to be replaced as frequently, reducing the amount of time your home is exposed to potential allergens and irritants associated with the installation of new flooring.

Finally, some flooring options can off-gas volatile organic compounds (VOCs) over time, which can trigger allergic reactions. Hardwood floors, especially those finished with low-VOC or VOC-free products, do not have this problem. However, it's important to note that some hardwood flooring can release harmful chemicals into the air, so proper maintenance and the choice of finishing products are crucial.

While no single solution can completely eliminate allergens from your home, choosing hardwood flooring can significantly reduce the concentration of these triggers in your living space, providing a healthier and more comfortable environment for allergy sufferers.

Frequently asked questions