Tipping Etiquette: Who Gets What In A Pooled House?

Whether or not the maître d' should be included in a tip pool is a divisive issue. While some people believe that the maître d' should be included in the tip pool, others argue that they should not. Ultimately, the decision of whether or not to include the maître d' in a tip pool depends on a variety of factors, including federal, state, and local laws, as well as the structure and culture of the business.

Should a Maitre d' be given more tip in comparison to a regular server?

Whether a Maître d' should be given more tips compared to a regular server depends on the restaurant's tipping structure and policies. Some restaurants implement a tip-pooling system, where tips are combined and redistributed among all employees, including the Maître d' and back-of-house staff. In this case, the amount received by each employee would depend on factors such as hours worked or a points-based system.

Other restaurants may have a tip-sharing policy, where servers have more autonomy over their tips and can choose to share a certain percentage or amount with other employees. In this scenario, the Maître d' may receive a smaller portion of the tips compared to a regular server, as they often have less direct involvement in table service.

According to federal law in the U.S., employees who receive over $30 in tips per month are considered "tipped employees" and can be paid less than the standard minimum wage, as long as their total earnings meet the federal minimum wage. This allows for a certain level of flexibility in how tips are distributed among staff.

Ultimately, the decision on how to distribute tips should be made with consideration for federal, state, and local laws, as well as the satisfaction of all employees, to ensure a collaborative and fair work environment.

Is it customary to tip the Maitre d' before sitting down?

Tipping the maitre d' is not always necessary. However, if you are a regular patron, you may want to tip the host $10 to $20 to cultivate your relationship and express gratitude for any special services. It is also appropriate to tip the maitre d' if they have gone out of their way to find you a table on a busy night. In this case, it is customary to offer $10 to $15 after being shown to the table. If you are dining with a large party, you should double or triple the tip, depending on the number of people.

In a pooled house, where tips are combined and redistributed among staff, the maitre d' may be included in the tip pool under certain conditions. According to the U.S. Department of Labor, employers who pay tipped employees the full minimum wage without applying a tip credit can allow non-tipped employees like the maitre d' to participate in the tip pool. However, it is important to note that direct participation in tip pooling by managers and supervisors is generally not allowed, and they are only entitled to tips specifically given to them for services they personally provide.

Ultimately, whether or not to tip the maitre d' before sitting down is at the customer's discretion and depends on factors such as the level of service provided and the frequency of visits to the restaurant.

What are the consequences of not adhering to tip pooling rules?

The consequences of not adhering to tip pooling rules can vary, but generally include legal and financial repercussions. Here are some of the potential consequences:

• Legal Action and Fines: Violating tip pooling regulations can result in hefty fines and lawsuits. The Fair Labor Standards Act (FLSA) protects tipped employees from wage theft and unfair tipping practices. Employers who break these laws may face significant financial penalties. In the United States, the Department of Labor (DOL) can assess penalties of up to $1,162 per violation, on top of back pay and damages that employees can sue for.
• Reputational Damage: Non-compliance with tip pooling rules can harm a business's reputation. Employees may be less inclined to work for a company known for shady tipping practices, and customers may be reluctant to support a business with unfair labor practices.
• Employee Dissatisfaction: Tip pooling is meant to foster teamwork and ensure equitable compensation. However, if tip pooling rules are not followed, it can lead to dissatisfaction among employees, especially those who feel they are not receiving their fair share of tips.
• Administrative Burden: Tip pooling requires accurate record-keeping and timely redistribution of tips. Failure to comply with these requirements can result in increased administrative burden and complexity in managing tips.
• Increased Costs: In addition to fines, employers who do not adhere to tip pooling rules may be required to pay employees the difference if their wages fall short of the minimum wage requirements. This can result in unexpected costs for the business.
• Loss of Talent: Employees may choose to leave a company that is not adhering to tip pooling rules, especially if they feel their tips are being unfairly distributed or withheld. This can lead to a loss of talented staff and increased turnover rates.

It is important to note that tip pooling laws can vary depending on the location of the business. Federal, state, and local laws may have specific regulations regarding tip pooling, and non-compliance with these laws can result in different consequences. It is always best to consult with legal professionals to ensure compliance with the applicable laws and avoid any negative consequences.

What are the advantages of tip pooling?

There are several advantages to tip pooling, which is a practice in the hospitality industry where tipped employees contribute the tips they’ve earned into a pool at the end of a shift. Here are some of the benefits:

Improved teamwork and group cohesion

With tip pooling, employees realise they are all in it together. As a result, teamwork and group cohesion improve because everyone knows a good customer experience usually results in a higher tip and more money in their pocket at the end of the day.

Staff are more likely to help each other

Similarly, tip pooling motivates every employee, regardless of their position, to help their coworkers when the need arises. So, for example, a host helping out with the busser’s duties when things get busy, keeps everything running smoothly. When that happens, guests will be happier and more likely to tip accordingly.

Fewer disputes over table assignments

Table assignments can cause bad feelings and disputes among servers that have a direct effect on the rest of the team. With tip pooling, there are no “bad” tables, and no one feels slighted because they have to work the corner near the kitchen door.

Increased sense of responsibility at all positions

With tip pooling, all positions experience an increased sense of responsibility because their actions can have a direct effect on the amount of tip they’ll receive at the end of the shift. As with the other pros on this list, that’s good for your customers, good for your team, and good for your business.

Equal attention to side work

During busy times, side work, such as keeping entryways clean and ketchup bottles filled, takes a backseat to getting customers seated, served, and out the door. But, with tip pooling, employees know that their tip depends on the total experience, so they’re more likely to give this side work the attention it deserves — even during the lunch and dinner rush.

Should restaurant owners implement a tip pooling system?

There are several factors to consider when deciding whether to implement a tip pooling system in a restaurant. Tip pooling can be beneficial in fostering teamwork and improving customer service, as all staff members are incentivized to work together to provide a positive experience for customers. It can also help ensure that all staff members, including those in supporting roles, are fairly compensated for their contributions to the customer experience. Additionally, tip pooling can reduce disputes over table assignments, as all tables are considered equally valuable when tips are pooled.

On the other hand, there are some potential drawbacks to consider. One of the main criticisms of tip pooling is that high-performing employees may feel that their hard work is not adequately rewarded, as they are sharing tips with those who may not put in the same level of effort. Tip pooling can also make it more difficult to identify low-performing employees, as everyone is receiving the same amount of tips regardless of their individual contributions. Additionally, there is a risk that employees may feel that the distribution of pooled tips is unfair, particularly if they feel that certain positions are not given the appropriate weight in the distribution system.

It is important to note that there are legal considerations to keep in mind when implementing a tip pooling system. According to federal law in the United States, managers and supervisors are not allowed to participate in tip pools and can only keep tips that are given directly to them by customers for services they provided solely. Additionally, employers are prohibited from retaining employees' tips for any purpose other than verifying or processing their paychecks; all tips are considered the property of the employees. While tip pooling can be mandatory, it must be implemented correctly to avoid violating federal and state laws and incurring fines.

Overall, whether or not to implement a tip pooling system is a decision that should be made in consultation with staff and with careful consideration of the potential benefits and drawbacks, as well as applicable legal requirements.

Frequently asked questions